James R. Payne M.D.
Aesthetic Plastic Surgery

1334 Nelson Avenue
Modesto, CA 95350
209.524.9904 T
209.524.4 1 0 1 F

Ask the Doctor

This option allows the patient to have direct contact with the physician. It is intended to provide helpful information to the client and allow them to reach out directly to the doctor about issues important to them. This form of communication is not intended to replace a formal interview and examination and should not be construed as definitive medical commentary and advice. TO ASK THE DOCTOR A QUESTION CLICK here OR SEND AN EMAIL TO drpayne@jamesrpaynemd.com WITH THE SUBJECT LINE Ask the Doctor.

Is it better to put breast implants on top of the muscle (subglandular) or under the muscle (subpectoral)?

Thursday, May 09, 2013

There are pros and cons to both approaches. Dr. Payne usually puts implants under the muscle for several reasons. First, implants placed under the muscle feel more natural than those placed on top of the muscle. In patients with thin skin and breast tissue implants placed on top of the muscle can more easily be seen and felt through the skin which is unnatural. They also are more likely to cause visible rippling of the breast which most patients very much do not like. Second, Dr. Payne believes that the risk of capsular contracture is lower when the implants are placed under the muscle. Capsular contracture is a condition where scar tissue forms around the implant and then tightens. As the scar tissue tightens the breast becomes firm and unnaturally round and tends to ride higher up on the chest causing noticeable asymmetry between the two breasts. Third, Dr. Payne believes that implants placed under the muscle look softer and more natural than implants placed on top of the muscle. Fourth, Dr. Payne believes that when mammograms are performed looking to detect breast cancer that it is easier for the radiologist to read the mammograms when the implants are placed under the muscle. This means a patient could have a breast cancer with microcalcifications and the implant on top of the muscle might make it harder for the radiologist to see these than if the implant had been put under the muscle.

Dr. Payne believes that the three main advantages of implants placed on top of the muscle is that for the first few days after surgery the patient has less pain than if the implants had gone under the muscle. If patients take the medication they are given after surgery this usually doesn’t make much difference one way or the other. Most patients are fairly comfortable following a breast augmentation operation within 3-5 days after surgery. A second reason is that implants placed on top of the muscle look more “fake” which is something that some women like. Remember that as time passes the breast fat and tissue will thin out and that an implant placed on top of the muscle might look good for a while but then some years later it might start to ripple and look bad. A third reason to go on top of the muscle is that if a woman is an athlete who competes in various activities where the arms are used (e.g. golf or tennis) it is possible that implants placed under the muscle might interfere with her athletic abilities whereas an implant placed on top of the muscle might be less likely to do this.

Breast Augmentation Tummy Tuck Facial Cosmetic Surgery

Breast Augmentation

While Dr. Payne is well versed in all aspects of aesthetic plastic surgery, his main area of specialty and interest is in breast augmentation.
Click here to learn more.

Tummy Tuck

One of the most rewarding procedures in cosmetic surgery, the tummy tuck has dramatic and long-lasting results.
Click here to learn more.

Facial Cosmetic Surgery

From brow lifts to nasal surgery, Dr. Payne's facial procedures offer some of the most dramatic transformations plastic surgery can provide.
Click here to learn more.

Breast Lift and Implants Massive Weight Loss Clients Laser and Skin Care Services

Breast Lift & Implants

This high-satisfaction procedure lifts and re-contours the breasts and can be accompanied with implants.
Click here to learn more.

Massive Weight Loss Clients

Dr. Payne offers various treatments for clients who experience massive weight loss due to traditional methods or bariatric surgery.
Click here to learn more.

Laser & Skin Care Services

Dr. Payne offers a variety of non-surgical anti-aging procedures and products for reducing wrinkles and rejuvenating the skin.
Click here to learn more.

Girl in black and white

Men and women alike undergo body changes as they age that cannot be remedied with dieting and exercise. Body contouring procedures can make clients look and feel better from head to toe. The immensely popular tummy tuck, liposuction for a wide variety of body areas, slimming the upper arms, Brazilian butt lifts and other buttock reshaping, lower body lifts, and other treatments may be rendered alone or in combination.

Click to learn more.

©2012 Dr. James R. Payne. All rights Reserved. Design by Never Boring Design, Modesto CA.